11 July, 2019 | Medicine
Gravity is the odd one out. Henrik Johansson is trying to change that. The other three fundamental forces of nature – the electromagnetic, weak and strong forces – and their associated force-carrying particles are united in a successful theoretical framework known as the Standard Model.

Gravity is the odd one out. Henrik Johansson is trying to do something about it. The other three fundamental forces of nature – the electromagnetic, weak and strong forces, together with their associated force-carrying particles – are united in a successful theoretical framework known as the Standard Model. Quantum mechanics forms the basis of this model, but gravity refuses to fit in. All quantum calculations involving the hypothetical particle of gravity, the graviton, inevitably produce infinities. Infinity is a meaningless answer and a disaster for a theory. The challenge is to tame these infinities.
Quantum mechanics and gravity, as described by Einstein’s general theory of relativity, are among the most successful theories in modern physics. General relativity describes our universe, where gravity keeps planets in orbit around their stars and holds us to the Earth. In the microscopic world of atoms and particles, however, the laws of quantum mechanics prevail. But to understand, for example, what happened at the birth of the universe in the Big Bang, or to resolve the paradoxes surrounding black holes, the two theories must be brought together. Attempts to develop a quantum mechanical theory of gravity – quantum gravity – have been under way for some 80 years. Albert Einstein himself devoted several decades of his life to searching for a theory that would unify the forces of nature.
During his doctoral studies in Los Angeles, Henrik Johansson discovered a possible way to simplify the calculations. Together with his colleague John Joseph Carrasco and supervisor Zvi Bern, he attempted to revive a potential theory of quantum gravity from the 1970s known as supergravity, an extension of Einstein’s theory of relativity.
Supergravity requires the existence of at least twice as many particles in the universe as those already known, meaning that it cannot describe the world as we have observed it so far. But that does not deter a theoretical physicist. If the calculations work, the theory could provide a key to the long-sought theory of quantum gravity.
A more serious problem was that many physicists believed supergravity would also produce infinities. But there was no proof. The calculations were simply too difficult and had led nowhere.
“If we had relied solely on the established methods, we would have needed to deal with (10^{25}) formulas. Not even the world’s most powerful computers could handle that. But we managed to reduce the number of contributions to just over 50, and after two years we had our answer: there were no infinities.”
Eliminating the infinities required sophisticated methods, a host of ingenious new tools and some clever tricks along the way. Among the most important discoveries was a particular kind of duality between gluons and gravitons.
Henrik Johansson noticed that the formulas used in quantum calculations had an underlying structure: one graviton corresponded to two gluons, the particles associated with the strong force. Gluons bind together the particles inside atomic nuclei and are part of the Standard Model, where they are described by a quantum mechanical theory known as quantum chromodynamics.
This duality suggests that gravity, too, should be describable using the quantum theories employed today.
“I saw the pattern and immediately realised that this was something big. But I had no idea just how significant it would become. We now have a trick for eliminating the infinities: first we perform quantum calculations for gluons and then translate the results so that they also apply to gravitons.”
The discovery became part of Henrik Johansson’s doctoral thesis, although the calculations were limited to a particular level of precision known as the fourth loop order. To obtain a definitive answer as to whether supergravity could be the long-awaited quantum theory, many more calculations are needed. The seventh loop order is the one that most physicists are interested in.
“Last summer, I completed the fifth loop order. It took more than five years to calculate, and no infinities have appeared yet. So the question is: is the infinity there, or is it some kind of miracle that we haven’t found it? That’s why we want to carry out these calculations.
“The next two orders require more than ten thousand formulas, and with our improved computational methods, I hope to complete them within a couple of years. Either we find an infinity, in which case supergravity is not correct, or we discover a miracle.”
After eleven years abroad, Henrik Johansson returned to Sweden in autumn 2014. He brought with him a PhD from UCLA and a framework for quantum gravity calculations – BCJ duality – named after himself and his two colleagues.
The detailed mathematics underlying the duality has yet to be developed, although it is clear that it involves some form of Lie algebra. This mathematical structure was developed more than a century ago by the Norwegian mathematician Sophus Lie and is widely used in modern physics.
“Perhaps the duality can be simplified even further. Perhaps it can be formulated more elegantly. But even though we don’t yet understand all the details, we have discovered an incredibly useful method.”
It took some time for physicists to embrace the new methods. Today, they are used, for example, in calculations involving gravitational waves, which were predicted by Einstein’s theory of relativity a century ago.
The waves were not detected until 2015, and the discovery was awarded the Nobel Prize just two years later. They originate from some of the most violent events in the universe, such as collisions between two black holes, and can now be calculated much more efficiently.